How to Evaluate AI Software for a Disability Law Firm: Ten Questions to Ask

Short answer: Evaluate AI software for a disability law firm the way you would evaluate a new associate: give it real work and check the result. The ten questions below come down to four tests. Can you verify what it says? Does it find what is missing? Was it built by someone who knows this work? And is your clients’ information protected in writing? A demonstration on the vendor’s sample file answers none of them. A test on your own files answers all four.

I have been a Certified Rehabilitation Counselor since 1996 and have testified as a Social Security vocational expert since 2014, and I built case development software for this field. So I have a side in this. Use the questions on every vendor, including mine.

Why is choosing legal AI harder for a disability practice?

Most legal AI is built for general practice: contracts, research, discovery. A disability case is different. The record is medical, the standards are SSA’s own regulations and rulings, the decisive questions are often vocational, and the fee is contingent. Software that summarizes documents well may still miss what decides a hearing. The questions below are written for that difference.

Questions 1 to 3: can you trust the output?

  1. Does every finding cite exhibit and page? If a statement about the record does not point to where it came from, a person has to find it again before it can be used. Ask to see a full report, not a screenshot.
  2. What does it do when the evidence is not there? The right answer is that it says so. A report that never says “not found in the record” is filling gaps with something.
  3. Does it show inconsistencies as well as support? A file has evidence on both sides. A tool that only collects what helps leaves you unprepared for the strongest points against the claim.

Questions 4 to 6: does it do the work you need?

  1. Is it a summary, or case development? A summary describes the file. Case development identifies what is missing and tells you what to ask the client and the treating sources to close each gap. Only the second changes the record.
  2. Does it cover the hearing? SSA mails the hearing notice at least 75 days ahead (20 CFR 404.938(a)), and written evidence is due no later than 5 business days before the hearing (20 CFR 404.935(a)). Ask what the software gives you inside that window: the response to the reasons for denial, the RFC the record supports, and questions for the vocational expert.
  3. Who built it, and have they done this work? Ask who designed the analysis and what their experience is with SSA disability cases. General document software and software built for this field read the same file differently.

Questions 7 and 8: is client information protected?

  1. Will you sign a written agreement before any upload, and what does it say? Ask for a business associate agreement and read it. It should limit use of the information to your matters, require safeguards and incident reporting, bind subcontractors, and provide for return or destruction when you leave.
  2. Who can see my files, and are they used for anything else? Get a direct answer, in the agreement, on whether client records are used for any purpose beyond serving your firm.

Ethics check. ABA Formal Opinion 512 (July 29, 2024) says lawyers using generative AI tools must fully consider their obligations, including competent representation, protecting client information and supervising those who assist them. Questions 1, 7 and 9 are how a firm shows it did.

Questions 9 and 10: will it work in your office?

  1. How does it fit our review process? Output should arrive in a form the responsible attorney or representative can review, correct and direct. Ask whether you can question a report and get the affected parts revised, or whether you receive a document and nothing more.
  2. Can we test it on our own cases first? This is the question that settles the others. Choose a few files you know well, with a hearing coming, and include one hard case. Compare the output with your own reading. Count the citations you checked and the ones that held.

How should you run the test?

  • Pick the files before you see the product. Otherwise you will choose cases that suit the demonstration.
  • Write down your own view first. Note what you think the strongest issue and the biggest gap are in each file. Then see whether the software found them, and whether it found something you missed.
  • Check citations by hand. Open the exhibit and page. Every one that supports a point you would argue, and a sample of the rest.
  • Have the person who will use it do the test. A partner’s impression of a demonstration is not the same as a paralegal’s experience with a file.
  • Measure with your own numbers. Time spent on the file before and after is the figure that matters to a contingent-fee practice.

What are the red flags?

  • The vendor will not let you test on your own files.
  • Reports read well and cite nothing.
  • Promises about case outcomes. No software can promise how a judge will decide.
  • Vague answers about where client information goes.
  • No one on the vendor’s side who has worked an SSA disability case.

How Precision Case Lens answers these questions

Precision Case Lens is SSA disability case development software built by a Social Security vocational expert. It does two things: Case Development, which shows what the record supports, what is inconsistent and what is missing, with a plan to close each gap; and Hearing Prep Blueprints, built from the developed record. Every finding is cited to the exhibit and page for the representative’s review.

The fairest test of any legal AI is your own files. Take the PCL Challenge Free Trial: four trial runs on four separate cases, with a signed business associate agreement in place before anything is uploaded. Or open a fully developed synthetic case on the free demo, no login required.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most important question to ask an AI vendor?

Whether every finding cites its source. In a disability file that means exhibit and page. A cited finding can be verified quickly. An uncited one has to be redone before anyone can rely on it.

Should we test AI software on real cases?

Yes, once a written confidentiality agreement is signed. Use files you already know well, including at least one difficult case, so you can judge the output against your own reading of the record.

Is a medical summary enough?

A summary tells you what is in the file. Case development also tells you what is missing and what to do about it while there is still time. For hearing work, ask for both.

How do we measure whether legal AI is working?

Use your own numbers. Before you start, note how long file review and hearing preparation take, how often evidence goes in late, and how often work is redone. Compare after several weeks.

From the same founder: Precision AI Group — AI intake and follow-up for law firms, built around your firm’s rules. For SSA disability case development, see Precision Case Lens.

Ask question ten first

Run Precision Case Lens on your own pre-hearing cases and judge the result yourself, or open a fully developed synthetic case on the free demo.

Take the PCL Challenge Free TrialSee a Developed Case — Free Demo

Each trial run returns a Premium Hearing Prep Blueprint. No login required to view the demo. Nothing to buy. Learn more at precisioncaselens.com or talk to Allan.

This article is general information for disability representatives, not legal advice. Precision Case Lens works for the representative; it does not represent claimants and does not guarantee outcomes.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top