Substance Use in Remission in an SSA Disability Case: The Question the Record Has to Answer

Short answer: When SSA finds a claimant disabled and the file contains medical evidence of drug addiction or alcoholism, 20 CFR 404.1535 asks one question: would the claimant still be disabled without drug or alcohol use? The test runs on the limitations that remain once the substance use is set aside. Remission is a fact the record has to document. The regulation asks about the limitations that would be left.

Robert Chen is a synthetic case in the public Precision Case Lens demo: a claimant with bipolar I disorder and post-traumatic stress disorder, with substance use in remission. It is worth studying because the mental-health evidence is substantial, and the substance question is the one that can decide the file even when the diagnoses are not in dispute. The demo’s report surfaces the DAA questions for attorney review. This article walks through what that review has to answer.

The test, in the regulation’s own steps

Section 404.1535(b)(1) names the key factor: whether SSA would still find the claimant disabled if the claimant stopped using drugs or alcohol. Section 404.1535(b)(2) turns that into two steps:

  1. Identify which of the current physical and mental limitations, the ones SSA relied on in the disability determination, would remain if the claimant stopped using.
  2. Decide whether those remaining limitations would be disabling.

If the remaining limitations would not be disabling, SSA finds the drug addiction or alcoholism is a contributing factor material to the determination of disability (404.1535(b)(2)(i)). If they would be disabling, the claimant is disabled independent of the substance use, and SSA finds it is not a contributing factor material (404.1535(b)(2)(ii)).

Why remission does not end the question

A substance use disorder in remission tells the adjudicator that use has stopped. It does not tell the adjudicator which symptoms belong to the mental disorders on their own. Bipolar disorder and PTSD can produce limits on concentration, pace, persistence, and tolerance for social contact that continue during abstinence. The file has to show which of those limits are present when substances are not in use. That is a question about the timeline of the record, not about the label on the diagnosis.

What the record has to show

  • Function during abstinence. Treatment notes, mental status examinations, and hospital or intensive outpatient records from periods without use. A record that documents function only during use leaves the central question unanswered.
  • Relapse episodes, and what the notes say around them. A relapse does not answer the question by itself, but the notes before and after it show how the mental symptoms behaved with and without substances.
  • A source statement that separates the two. A treating-source opinion that lists limits without saying whether they would persist without substance use is the gap most often left in these files. Ask the source the question directly.
  • One consistent timeline. Dates of use, dates of remission, and the treatment between them, matched across the intake interview, the claimant’s reports, and the treatment records.

Where the mental limits do the work

Under 20 CFR 404.1569a(c)(1), difficulty functioning because of nervousness, anxiety, or depression, difficulty maintaining attention or concentrating, and difficulty understanding or remembering detailed instructions are all nonexertional limitations. In a bipolar and PTSD case, those are often the limits that decide the remaining-limitations test. A general statement that the claimant has moderate limitations will not carry that weight. Each limit needs a specific description, a source, and a date range.

The hearing question

At the hearing, expect the judge to focus on the substance question. The ALJ poses the hypotheticals to the vocational expert, so the representative’s job is to make sure the hypotheticals include the limitations that would remain without substance use, each tied to an exhibit and page. If the hypothetical describes the claimant during use, the vocational answer describes the claimant during use. Say so on the record, and ask the VE to address the remaining limitations expressly.

Keep the two timelines separate. The DAA test asks about the claimant without substance use. Mark every exhibit that describes the claimant during use in the development notes, so no one builds a hypothetical from the wrong period.

How Precision Case Lens helps

Precision Case Lens is SSA disability case development software built by a Social Security Vocational Expert. Its reports read the whole file, show what the record supports, what is inconsistent, and what is missing, and they raise the drug addiction and alcoholism questions for attorney review instead of leaving them buried in a medical summary. The Cure Plan lists the treating-source and client questions that would close the gap, each cited to exhibit and page.

See the Robert Chen case on the free Precision Case Lens demo. It uses synthetic data, requires no login, and shows what a developed DAA question looks like on the page.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the DAA question in an SSA case?

SSA’s regulation at 20 CFR 404.1535 applies after SSA finds a claimant disabled and has medical evidence of drug addiction or alcoholism. It asks whether that drug addiction or alcoholism is a contributing factor material to the determination of disability.

What is the key factor SSA examines?

Under 20 CFR 404.1535(b)(1), the key factor is whether SSA would still find the claimant disabled if the claimant stopped using drugs or alcohol. SSA identifies which current physical and mental limitations would remain without use, then decides whether those remaining limitations would be disabling (404.1535(b)(2)).

What happens if the remaining limitations are not disabling?

Under 404.1535(b)(2)(i), SSA then finds the drug addiction or alcoholism is a contributing factor material to the determination of disability. If the remaining limitations are disabling, SSA finds the substance use is not a contributing factor material (404.1535(b)(2)(ii)).

Does remission settle the question?

Not by itself. Remission is a fact the record must document, but the regulation asks which limitations would remain once substance use is set aside, and whether those limitations are disabling. The evidence has to answer that question directly.

Find the limits that remain before the hearing

Read a developed synthetic SSA case on the free Precision Case Lens demo, or take the PCL Challenge on your own pre-hearing case.

Take the PCL Challenge Free TrialSee a Developed Case — Free Demo

Each trial run returns a Premium Hearing Prep Blueprint. No login required to view the demo. Nothing to buy. Learn more at precisioncaselens.com or talk to Allan.

This article is general information for disability representatives, not legal advice. Precision Case Lens works for the representative; it does not represent claimants and does not guarantee outcomes.

Scroll to Top