Short answer: A veteran who does not meet the percentage standards in 38 CFR § 4.16(a) can still be rated totally disabled based on individual unemployability. Section 4.16(b) states VA’s established policy that all veterans who are unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation by reason of service-connected disabilities shall be rated totally disabled. When the percentages are not met, the rating board submits the case to the Director, Compensation Service, for extra-schedular consideration, with a full statement of the veteran’s disabilities, employment history, and educational and vocational attainment.
Many veterans are told they “don’t qualify” for Total Disability based on Individual Unemployability (TDIU) because their ratings are too low. That statement describes only one of the two paragraphs in the regulation. This article explains the second paragraph, how it differs from the first, and why vocational evidence carries so much of the weight in these claims.
What are the percentage standards in § 4.16(a)?
Paragraph (a) is the schedular route. It applies when a veteran has one service-connected disability ratable at 60 percent or more, or two or more disabilities with at least one ratable at 40 percent or more and a combined rating of 70 percent or more. For the purpose of reaching the single 60 or 40 percent disability, certain groups are treated as one disability, including disabilities of one or both upper or lower extremities, disabilities from a common etiology or a single accident, and disabilities affecting a single body system.
A veteran who meets those numbers still has to show inability to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation. A veteran who does not meet them moves to paragraph (b).
What does § 4.16(b) say?
Paragraph (b) has three sentences, and each one does something.
- The policy. It is the established policy of the Department of Veterans Affairs that all veterans who are unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation by reason of service-connected disabilities shall be rated totally disabled.
- The referral. Rating boards should therefore submit to the Director, Compensation Service, for extra-schedular consideration all cases of veterans who are unemployable by reason of service-connected disabilities but who fail to meet the percentage standards in paragraph (a).
- The statement. The rating board will include a full statement as to the veteran’s service-connected disabilities, employment history, educational and vocational attainment, and all other factors having a bearing on the issue.
The word “all” in the first sentence is the point. The percentages in paragraph (a) decide which route a claim takes. They do not decide whether a veteran with lower ratings can be found unemployable.
Who is likely to need the extra-schedular route?
Ratings measure average impairment across all veterans with a condition. Individual unemployability is about one person. The two can diverge, and vocational practice shows some common patterns:
- a veteran with a single condition rated at 40 or 50 percent whose entire work history is in heavy physical labor that the condition now rules out;
- a veteran with several moderate ratings that combine below 70 percent but that together affect standing, lifting, concentration and attendance;
- a veteran with limited education and no skills that carry into sedentary work; and
- a veteran whose condition causes frequent unscheduled absences that no employer tolerates, whatever the rating.
These are examples of fact patterns, not rules. Each claim is decided on its own evidence.
What stays the same under paragraph (b)?
Several rules apply on both routes.
- The cause must be service-connected disability. Paragraph (b) refers to veterans who are unemployable “by reason of service-connected disabilities.” The evidence should isolate what those conditions do to the ability to work.
- Age is not a factor. Under 38 CFR § 4.19, age may not be considered in evaluating service-connected disability, and unemployability associated with advancing age may not be used as a basis for a total disability rating. Section 3.341(a) likewise requires that unemployability be shown without regard to advancing age.
- Marginal employment is not substantially gainful employment. Paragraph (a) says so, and it describes marginal employment by reference to the Census Bureau poverty threshold for one person and, on a facts-found basis, to work in a protected environment such as a family business or sheltered workshop.
- The reason work ended matters. Paragraph (a) requires consideration, in all claims, of the nature of the employment and the reason for termination.
Why does vocational evidence matter more here?
On the schedular route, the percentages do part of the work. On the extra-schedular route, the claim rests almost entirely on showing why this particular veteran cannot work. The regulation itself lists what the decision maker needs: service-connected disabilities, employment history, educational attainment, vocational attainment, and every other factor bearing on the issue.
Medical records cover the first item. They rarely cover the rest. A treatment note does not say what skill level the veteran’s past jobs required, whether those skills transfer to lighter work, or how many absences an employer will accept. A vocational evaluation is organized around exactly those subjects, which is why it fits the extra-schedular statement so closely.
What does a vocational evaluation for a § 4.16(b) claim include?
- Document review. Hospital, physician, psychiatrist, psychologist and counselor records, and VA disability documentation.
- Diagnostic vocational interview. Age, education, work history, skills, impairments, treatment and limitations, in person or remote.
- Vocational testing when indicated. Aptitudes, and where relevant attention, concentration, memory and other cognitive measures.
- Transferable skills analysis. Whether skills from past work can be used in other occupations within the service-connected limitations.
- Labor market research. Whether occupations the veteran can actually perform exist in significant numbers.
- The opinion. Whether the veteran can secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation, stated in vocational terms and tied to the service-connected conditions.
Our TDIU vocational evaluation process describes these steps in more detail.
What mistakes hurt extra-schedular claims?
- Stopping at the percentages. Not meeting paragraph (a) is the starting point for paragraph (b), not the end of the claim.
- Submitting only medical evidence. The regulation calls for employment, educational and vocational facts. If the file lacks them, the decision maker has little to work with.
- Mixing service-connected and other conditions. An opinion that the veteran cannot work because of everything combined does not answer the question the regulation asks.
- A thin work history. Job titles and dates are not enough. The duties, physical demands, skill level and reason for leaving each job should be in the record.
Allan S. Billehus, MS, EdS, CRC, LPC, has been a Certified Rehabilitation Counselor since 1996 and a Social Security vocational expert since 2014. Veterans with questions about how to raise or appeal a TDIU claim should speak with a VA-accredited representative or attorney.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I get TDIU with a combined rating under 70 percent?
It is possible. 38 CFR § 4.16(b) states that all veterans who are unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation by reason of service-connected disabilities shall be rated totally disabled, and it provides for extra-schedular consideration when the percentage standards in § 4.16(a) are not met.
Who decides an extra-schedular TDIU claim?
Under § 4.16(b), rating boards submit these cases to the Director, Compensation Service, for extra-schedular consideration.
What has to be in the file for extra-schedular consideration?
The regulation requires the rating board to include a full statement of the veteran’s service-connected disabilities, employment history, educational and vocational attainment, and all other factors having a bearing on the issue.
Is the standard for unemployability lower or higher under 4.16(b)?
The regulation uses the same core test in both paragraphs: inability to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation because of service-connected disabilities. What differs is the route the claim takes and how much the outcome depends on the evidence in the file.
Ratings below the TDIU thresholds?
SouthEast Vocational Experts prepares vocational evaluations for TDIU claims, including extra-schedular claims under 38 CFR § 4.16(b). We primarily work in the Southeast and provide services nationally.
Request a TDIU Vocational EvaluationCall (404) 735-6900This article is general information about vocational evaluation, not legal advice. For advice about a specific claim or case, consult a VA-accredited representative or a licensed attorney.

