Loss of Earning Capacity in a Personal Injury Case: What a Vocational Expert Evaluates

Short answer: Loss of earning capacity is the difference between what a person was able to earn before an injury and what the person is able to earn after it. A forensic vocational expert measures it by establishing pre-injury earning capacity, establishing post-injury earning capacity from the medical restrictions, the person’s skills and the labor market, and explaining the gap. The related measure, loss of labor market access, is the share of occupations the person could perform before the injury and can no longer perform.

In a personal injury case, past wage loss can usually be read from pay records. Future loss cannot. It depends on what work the injured person can still do, whether that work exists where the person lives, and what it pays. Those are vocational questions. This article describes how a vocational evaluation answers them and what attorneys on either side should expect from one.

How is loss of earning capacity different from lost wages?

Lost wages look backward at earnings actually missed. Earning capacity looks at ability. A person who returns to the same employer at the same pay may still have lost capacity if the injury closes off promotion, overtime, or the heavier work the person would otherwise have been able to take. A person who was between jobs when injured had no wages to lose and may still have lost a great deal of capacity. The rules for what is recoverable are set by the law of the jurisdiction and are for counsel. The vocational evaluation supplies the facts and opinions the claim is built on.

How does a vocational expert establish pre-injury earning capacity?

The starting point is the person as they were before the injury:

  • education, training, licenses and certifications;
  • work history, job duties and the skills each job developed;
  • earnings history, including the direction it was heading;
  • age and the stage of the person’s career; and
  • any health conditions or limitations that were already present.

Actual earnings are evidence of capacity, but they are not always the same thing. A recent graduate, a worker who had just finished training, or a parent who had stepped out of the workforce may have had a capacity well above their last pay stub. The opinion has to explain why, using the person’s record and occupational data, without speculating.

How is post-injury earning capacity determined?

A sound evaluation follows a sequence, and each step should be visible in the report.

  1. Medical record review and chronology. The records are reviewed for diagnoses, treatment and, above all, the permanent functional restrictions set by treating and examining providers. The vocational expert does not set medical restrictions.
  2. Diagnostic vocational interview. Education, work history, daily functioning, treatment and the person’s own account of what they can and cannot do.
  3. Vocational testing when indicated. Achievement, aptitude, interest and work-sample measures, where the case needs objective data on what the person can learn and do.
  4. Transferable skills analysis. Whether skills from past work carry over to occupations within the restrictions.
  5. Labor market survey and research. Whether those occupations exist in the relevant geographic area, what employers require, and what the work pays.
  6. Opinions. Employability, placeability, the occupations that remain, and expected earnings in them.

What is loss of labor market access?

Earnings do not capture everything. Two people with the same post-injury wage can be in very different positions if one has hundreds of suitable occupations to choose from and the other has a handful. Loss of labor market access compares the range of occupations open to the person before the injury with the range open afterward. A narrower range means fewer openings to apply for, longer job searches, and more exposure if a job ends. It is reported alongside the earnings analysis, and it is especially useful when the wage difference by itself understates the change.

How does the vocational expert work with other experts?

Vocational opinions sit between the medical evidence and the economic calculation.

  • Physicians, psychologists and work capacity evaluators supply the functional restrictions the analysis starts from.
  • Economists take the vocational opinions on occupations and earnings and calculate loss over the person’s work life.
  • Life care planners address future care needs. The vocational expert coordinates with them so the plan and the vocational opinions rest on the same picture of the person’s function.

Where retraining is realistic, the evaluation can include a rehabilitation plan that sets out the training, its length, and the earning capacity expected at the end.

What makes a loss of earning capacity opinion hold up?

In federal court, Federal Rule of Evidence 702 requires the proponent of expert testimony to show that it is more likely than not that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, is the product of reliable principles and methods, and reflects a reliable application of those principles and methods to the facts of the case. State courts apply their own versions of the standard. For a vocational opinion, that translates into practical questions:

  • Were the medical restrictions taken from the record, and from which provider?
  • Is each occupation identified consistent with every restriction?
  • Is the wage and employment data current, sourced and specific to the relevant area?
  • Were pre-existing conditions and the pre-injury earnings record accounted for?
  • Could another vocational expert follow the same steps and reach the same result?

The same questions are the outline for reviewing an opposing expert’s report. A file consultation, without testimony, is often enough to identify where a report’s method breaks down.

What should an attorney send for the evaluation?

  • medical records, including any functional capacity evaluation and statements of permanent restrictions;
  • employment records, job descriptions and earnings records for several years before the injury;
  • school and training records;
  • deposition transcripts and interrogatory answers that touch on work and function; and
  • the reports of other experts in the case.

SouthEast Vocational Experts provides loss of earning capacity analysis, loss of labor market access analysis, labor market surveys, file consultation and vocational expert testimony in personal injury matters including auto liability, general and product liability, medical malpractice and wrongful death. Allan S. Billehus, MS, EdS, CRC, LPC, has been a Certified Rehabilitation Counselor since 1996 and a Social Security vocational expert since 2014.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between lost wages and loss of earning capacity?

Lost wages are the earnings a person actually missed because of the injury. Loss of earning capacity is the reduction in what the person is able to earn in the labor market going forward. A person can have one without the other.

Does a vocational expert calculate the total damages figure?

The vocational expert gives opinions on employability, the occupations that remain open, and expected earnings before and after the injury. An economist commonly uses those opinions to calculate present value over the person’s work life.

Can earning capacity be evaluated for someone with little or no work history?

Yes. For a young person, a student or someone outside the workforce, the evaluation relies more heavily on education, testing, interests and the occupations those support, because there is no earnings record to rely on.

When should a vocational expert be retained?

After the medical picture is reasonably stable and there are opinions on permanent restrictions, and early enough to allow for records review, an interview, testing and labor market research before disclosure deadlines.

Need a loss of earning capacity analysis?

SouthEast Vocational Experts provides forensic vocational evaluations, file consultations and vocational expert testimony for plaintiff and defense counsel. We primarily work in the Southeast and provide services nationally.

Request a Free ConsultationCall (404) 735-6900

This article is general information about vocational evaluation, not legal advice. For advice about a specific claim or case, consult a VA-accredited representative or a licensed attorney.

Scroll to Top