Short answer: ABA Formal Opinion 512 (July 29, 2024) does not ban AI for law firms. It says lawyers using generative AI tools must fully consider their existing ethical obligations: competent representation, protecting client information, communicating with clients, supervising employees and others who assist them, advancing only meritorious claims, candor toward the tribunal, and reasonable fees. The practical test for any legal AI is simple: can you check its work, and do you know where your client’s information goes?
I have been a Certified Rehabilitation Counselor since 1996 and have testified as a Social Security vocational expert since 2014. I am not an ethics lawyer, and this article is not legal advice. It is a working checklist, written from the opinion itself, for a disability practice that wants to use AI automation without creating a new problem.
What does ABA Formal Opinion 512 actually say?
The opinion is fifteen pages, and its opening sentence carries the whole message: to ensure clients are protected, lawyers using generative AI tools must fully consider their applicable ethical obligations. It then walks through those obligations one at a time. The ABA’s announcement names four Model Rules that principally apply: Rule 1.1 (competence), Rule 1.6 (confidentiality), Rule 1.4 (communication) and Rule 1.5 (fees). The opinion also covers supervision and candor toward the tribunal.
The committee calls its own guidance general. It notes that the tools keep changing and that it and state and local bar ethics committees will likely keep issuing updated guidance. Treat the checklist below as a floor, then read your own state’s rules.
Competence: do you understand the tool well enough to rely on it?
Rule 1.1 requires the legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness and preparation reasonably necessary for the representation. The ABA points out that this includes understanding the benefits and risks of the technology used to deliver legal services. You do not have to be an engineer. You do have to know what the tool is good at, where it fails, and how you will catch a failure.
- Can someone at the firm explain, in plain words, what the tool does with a file?
- Does every statement it produces point to a source you can open and read?
- Is there a named person who reviews the output before it is used?
Confidentiality: where does client information go?
Rule 1.6 covers all information relating to the representation, whatever its source, unless the client gives informed consent. A disability file is almost entirely medical records, so this is the first question, not the last.
- Is there a written agreement that limits what the vendor may do with client information?
- Is client information used for anything beyond your matter?
- What happens to the information when you stop using the service?
- Have you decided whether, and how, to tell clients?
Communication: what do clients need to know?
Rule 1.4(a)(2) requires a lawyer to reasonably consult with the client about the means by which the client’s objectives are to be accomplished. The opinion treats the use of AI tools as something that can fall within that duty. One way to handle it is in the engagement agreement, so the conversation happens once, in writing, at the start.
Supervision: who is responsible for the output?
The opinion lists the duty to supervise employees and others who assist the lawyer among the obligations that apply. In practice that means a written firm policy, training for the staff who use the tool, and a rule that nothing produced by AI workflow automation leaves the office without review by the responsible attorney. Software does not change who signs.
The rule that covers every other rule: the person who signs a document is responsible for everything in it, no matter what drafted the first version.
Candor: can you verify what you file?
The opinion names candor toward the tribunal and the duty to advance only meritorious claims and contentions. For a disability practice, that comes down to the brief and the hearing. Every factual statement in a pre-hearing brief should trace to an exhibit and page, and every citation to a regulation or ruling should be read at the source before it is relied on. If a tool gives you a conclusion with no citation, you have something to investigate, not something to file.
Fees: what can you charge for?
Rule 1.5 requires reasonable fees and expenses. The ABA’s summary gives a concrete example: a lawyer who spends fifteen minutes entering information into a tool may charge for that time and for the time needed to review the draft for accuracy and completeness, but in most circumstances cannot charge a client for learning how to use the tool. Most SSA disability work is contingent and subject to SSA’s own fee approval, so the larger effect of AI for SSA disability practices is on the firm’s cost of doing the work, not on the bill.
What about SSA representatives who are not attorneys?
The ABA opinion speaks to lawyers. SSA’s rules of conduct speak to everyone who represents a claimant. Under 20 CFR 404.1740(b)(3)(i), competent representation requires the knowledge, skill, thoroughness and preparation reasonably necessary for the representation, and a representative must know the significant issues in a claim and have reasonable and adequate familiarity with the evidence in the case. A tool can help you reach that familiarity. It cannot hold it for you.
A one-page checklist
- Policy. Write down which tools are approved and for what work.
- Agreement. Get the vendor’s confidentiality terms in a signed contract before any client file is shared.
- Citations. Use tools that cite the source for every finding, and spot-check those citations.
- Review. Name the attorney who reviews and signs.
- Clients. Decide what your engagement agreement says about AI.
- Training. Train staff, and repeat it when the tools change.
- State rules. Read your own bar’s guidance and follow the stricter rule.
How Precision Case Lens fits
Precision Case Lens is SSA disability case development software built by a Social Security vocational expert. It returns case development and hearing preparation work product for the representative’s review, with every finding cited to the exhibit and page so the attorney or representative can check it against the record before relying on it.
The fairest test of any legal AI is your own files. Take the PCL Challenge Free Trial: four trial runs on four separate cases, with a signed business associate agreement in place before anything is uploaded. Or open a fully developed synthetic case on the free demo, no login required.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is ABA Formal Opinion 512?
It is the American Bar Association’s first formal ethics opinion on generative AI tools, issued July 29, 2024 by the Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility. It applies existing duties under the ABA Model Rules to a lawyer’s use of those tools.
Does Formal Opinion 512 ban AI for law firms?
No. The opinion does not prohibit the tools. It says lawyers who use them must fully consider their ethical obligations, including competence, protecting client information, communicating with clients, supervising others, candor toward the tribunal and charging reasonable fees.
Is the opinion binding in my state?
ABA formal opinions interpret the ABA Model Rules and are guidance. Each state adopts and enforces its own rules, and state and local bar ethics committees issue their own guidance. Check your jurisdiction’s rules and opinions.
Do these duties apply to non-attorney representatives in SSA cases?
The ABA opinion addresses lawyers. Separately, SSA’s own rules of conduct at 20 CFR 404.1740 require every representative, attorney or not, to provide competent representation and to have reasonable and adequate familiarity with the evidence in the case.
From the same founder: Precision AI Group — AI intake and follow-up for law firms, built around your firm’s rules. For SSA disability case development, see Precision Case Lens.
Check the work yourself
Run Precision Case Lens on your own pre-hearing cases and verify every finding against the exhibit and page it cites. A signed business associate agreement comes first.
Take the PCL Challenge Free TrialSee a Developed Case — Free DemoEach trial run returns a Premium Hearing Prep Blueprint. No login required to view the demo. Nothing to buy. Learn more at precisioncaselens.com or talk to Allan.
This article is general information for disability representatives, not legal advice. Precision Case Lens works for the representative; it does not represent claimants and does not guarantee outcomes.

