Can You Work and Still Get TDIU? Marginal Employment and Protected Work Environments

Short answer: Yes, in some situations. Under 38 CFR § 4.16(a), marginal employment is not substantially gainful employment. Marginal employment generally exists when a veteran’s earned annual income does not exceed the U.S. Census Bureau poverty threshold for one person. It can also be found on a “facts found” basis when earnings are higher, and the regulation’s own example is employment in a protected environment such as a family business or sheltered workshop.

Many veterans assume that any paycheck ends a claim for Total Disability based on Individual Unemployability (TDIU). The regulation does not say that. It asks whether the veteran can secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation, and it sets apart a category of work that does not count. This article explains that category and the evidence that documents it.

What does the regulation say about working while claiming TDIU?

Section 4.16(a) allows a total rating when a veteran is, in the judgment of the rating agency, unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation as a result of service-connected disabilities. The same paragraph then states that marginal employment shall not be considered substantially gainful employment. It closes with an instruction that applies to every claim: consideration shall be given to the nature of the employment and the reason for termination.

So the regulation describes two different kinds of work. One is substantially gainful. The other is marginal. A veteran who is doing only marginal work has not shown, by that work alone, the ability to hold a substantially gainful occupation.

What is marginal employment?

The regulation describes two routes.

  • The income route. Marginal employment generally shall be deemed to exist when the veteran’s earned annual income does not exceed the amount the U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census, establishes as the poverty threshold for one person. The threshold is updated by the Census Bureau, so the figure for the year in question should be checked at the source.
  • The facts-found route. Marginal employment may also be held to exist when earned annual income exceeds the poverty threshold. The regulation says this “includes but is not limited to” employment in a protected environment such as a family business or sheltered workshop.

Two details in the wording matter. The test refers to earned income, which is income from work. And the phrase “includes but is not limited to” means the two named examples are illustrations, not a closed list.

What is a protected work environment?

The regulation names a family business and a sheltered workshop and stops there. It does not list the features that make a job protected. That leaves a factual question in each claim: is this veteran holding the job on the same terms as any other worker, or is the job being held together by allowances made because of the disability?

From a vocational standpoint, the features that separate protected work from competitive work are usually concrete and observable:

  • duties removed from the job or handed to coworkers;
  • a reduced or flexible schedule that other employees in the same position do not receive;
  • extra breaks, rest periods or time away from the work area;
  • lower productivity or more errors tolerated than the employer accepts from others;
  • absences, late arrivals and early departures excused beyond the employer’s normal policy;
  • closer supervision or repeated redirection; and
  • an employer who is a relative or friend and who keeps the veteran on for personal reasons.

None of these is a legal test. They are the facts a decision maker needs in order to judge whether the work is protected.

Does VA look at why a job ended?

Yes. Section 4.16(a) requires consideration of the nature of the employment and the reason for termination in all claims. A related regulation, 38 CFR § 4.18, says a veteran may be considered unemployable upon termination of employment that was provided on account of disability, or in which special consideration was given on account of the disability, when it is satisfactorily shown that the veteran is unable to secure further employment.

Section 4.18 also directs that the circumstances of employment be considered in individual claims. It refers to employment that was only occasional, intermittent, tryout or unsuccessful, or that eventually terminated on account of the disability. A work history made up of short jobs that ended for disability-related reasons is therefore evidence about employability, and should be laid out job by job.

What evidence shows that a job is marginal or protected?

The strongest files describe the job in specifics. Useful evidence includes:

  • earnings records for each year in question;
  • a statement from the employer or supervisor describing the allowances made and whether other employees receive them;
  • attendance and leave records;
  • a written job description, compared with what the veteran actually does;
  • statements from coworkers or family members who see the veteran at work; and
  • for past jobs, the dates worked and the reason each job ended.

General statements such as “my boss is understanding” carry less weight than a list of the specific duties the veteran no longer performs and the number of days missed.

How does a vocational expert analyze marginal or protected work?

A vocational evaluation puts the job in occupational terms. The analysis generally covers three things.

  1. How the occupation is normally performed. The usual duties, physical and mental demands, pace, attendance expectations and supervision for that occupation with a competitive employer.
  2. How this veteran performs it. The duties actually done, the hours actually worked and every allowance the employer makes, drawn from the interview, the records and employer statements.
  3. The gap between the two. Whether the veteran would keep the job if the allowances were withdrawn, and whether the veteran could obtain and keep comparable work with an employer who has no personal reason to make them.

The evaluation also reviews the medical and psychological records, takes a full education and work history, uses testing when the case calls for it, and includes labor market research where needed. Our TDIU vocational evaluation process describes each step. Allan S. Billehus, MS, EdS, CRC, LPC, has been a Certified Rehabilitation Counselor since 1996 and a Social Security vocational expert since 2014.

What mistakes weaken these claims?

  • Reporting the job title without the allowances. A title suggests a full competitive job. The file needs to show what the veteran actually does.
  • Leaving out the reason a job ended. The regulation requires VA to consider it, so the record should state it.
  • Treating a family job as automatically protected. Working for a relative is the regulation’s example, but the claim still needs the facts that show the protection.
  • Relying on income alone. Earnings above the poverty threshold do not end the question, because the facts-found route exists for those cases.

Whether a particular job is marginal is decided by VA on the evidence. A veteran with questions about a specific claim should speak with a VA-accredited representative or attorney.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I have a job and still qualify for TDIU?

Sometimes. Under 38 CFR § 4.16(a), marginal employment is not considered substantially gainful employment. Work can be marginal because earned annual income is at or below the Census Bureau poverty threshold for one person, or on the facts of the job even when earnings are higher.

What is a protected work environment?

The regulation does not give a full definition. It gives two examples of employment in a protected environment: a family business and a sheltered workshop. In practice the question is whether the job exists and continues only because the employer makes allowances that an ordinary competitive employer would not make.

Does household income count toward the poverty threshold test?

The regulation refers to the veteran’s own earned annual income. It does not refer to a spouse’s earnings or to household income.

How does a vocational expert help with a marginal employment question?

A vocational expert compares the job as the veteran actually performs it with the way that occupation is normally performed for a competitive employer, and documents the differences in hours, duties, productivity, supervision and attendance.

Working, but only with allowances?

SouthEast Vocational Experts prepares TDIU vocational evaluations that document how a veteran’s job compares with competitive employment. We primarily work in the Southeast and provide services nationally.

Request a TDIU Vocational EvaluationCall (404) 735-6900

This article is general information about vocational evaluation, not legal advice. For advice about a specific claim or case, consult a VA-accredited representative or a licensed attorney.

Scroll to Top